Publish Originally, Syndicate Elsewhere

16 Jan 2025

Shreyas Prakash headshot

Shreyas Prakash

Writing for yourself on your personal website is the purest form of self-expression on the internet. It avoids any trappings from the algorithmic maze. And there are no digital echo chambers. It’s just you and your ideas in your own cozy little garden.

We’re witnessing the renaissance of personal websites. As social platforms become increasingly unstable, more creators are rediscovering the power of digital sovereignty.

The only thing which I found broken (or missing) is a sense of participation between personal websites. It’s inordinately difficult for bloggers to talk with each other without relying on social media as the bridge (more on ‘bridges’ later). You see us sharing blogpost links on platforms to increase the surface area of our ideas written.

I found myself on the receiving end of this strange paradox. I craved for the reach social media offered, but yet wanted the autonomy to own and maintain my own personal pin code on the internet, where I write (selfishly) for myself.

Last year I focussed less on the “distribution” of ideas, and put in efforts more to the actual “creation” of them. It was still an itch I couldn’t scratch, until I was recently introduced to this concept of POSSE — Publish Own Sire, Syndicate Elsewhere. An IndieWeb solution to maintain your independence while participating in the larger internet discourse.

Calling POSSE, a concept might be too reductive. It’s a movement in itself picking up steam with the rise of various IndieWeb sister-concepts and other ideologically inclined social media platforms that faciliateed this movement such as Bluesky, Mastodon, Threads etc. Zach’s video on POSSE is a useful introduction to the idea.

So I wanted to stretch this idea as much as possible and figured out a solution to ditch the platform dependent comments (Ghost comments) for a more platform agnostic webmentions that gathered mentions of your blogpost across the internet, and into your blog (automagically) using the Brid.gy protocol.

I am not internet-famous, and don’t really have much of internet mentions. My first hello-world demo was simply mentioning my own post on Mastodon 😂

The final implementation used Webmentions to pull those cross-platform interactions back into the site, so a comment on Mastodon could still show up as part of the conversation around the original post.

Jokes aside, on a more tactical front, I will show you how you could implement Webmentions to your own Ghost blog.

The rest of the blog goes into the nitty-gritty on how to set this up:

Let’s start by telling the internet that your site CAN receive webmentions.

Add these lines to your Ghost header via Custom Injection. Your site needs to know how to display these inter-website conversations. We’ll add specialized CSS to your site header that handles everything from avatar displays to comment threading. This creates a clean, professional look that rivals any social media platform. I was inspired by Maggie Appleton’s webmentions on her site, and I quickly hacked together a prototype using Claude Projects.

Add these lines to the Ghost header as well via Custom Injection. This includes setting up indieweb authorisation, webmentions as well as webmention related styles:

<link rel="microsub" href="https://aperture.p3k.io/microsub/1003">
<link rel="authorization_endpoint" href="https://indieauth.com/auth">
<link rel="token_endpoint" href="https://tokens.indieauth.com/token">
<link rel="me" href="https://github.com/[github-profile]">

<link rel="webmention" href="https://webmention.io/www.[website-name].com/webmention">
<link rel="pingback" href="https://webmention.io/[website-name].com/[code]">

<!-- <link rel="webmention" href="https://webmention.io/[website-name].com/webmention">
<link rel="pingback" href="https://webmention.io/[website-name].com/[code]"> -->


<style>
  /* Container */
.wm-container {
    background: var(--color-four);
    border-radius: var(--border-radius);
    box-shadow: 0 4px 12px var(--opacity-four);
    padding: 2.5rem;
    margin: 4rem 0 6rem;
}

/* Header */
.wm-header {
    font-family: var(--font-family-one);
    font-size: 2.8rem;
    font-weight: var(--font-weight-one-bold);
    color: var(--color-font-one);
    margin-bottom: 2rem;
}

/* Likes and Retweets Section */
.wm-avatar-grid {
    display: flex;
    align-items: center;
    padding-bottom: 2rem;
    margin-bottom: 2rem;
    border-bottom: var(--border) var(--color-border-one);
}

.wm-avatar-grid .wm-avatar-link {
    width: 40px;
    height: 40px;
    margin-right: -10px;
    position: relative;
    z-index: 1;
}

.wm-avatar-grid .wm-avatar-img {
    width: 100%;
    height: 100%;
    border-radius: 50%;
    border: 2px solid var(--color-four);
    object-fit: cover;
}

.wm-reactions-count {
    font-size: 1.6rem;
    color: var(--color-font-one);
    margin-left: 1.5rem;
}

/* Comments Section */
.wm-mention-item {
    display: grid;
    grid-template-columns: 40px 1fr;
    gap: 15px;
    padding: 20px 0;
    border-bottom: var(--border) var(--color-border-one);
}

.wm-mention-item:last-child {
    border-bottom: none;
}

/* Author Image */
.wm-author-img {
    width: 40px;
    height: 40px;
    border-radius: 50%;
    object-fit: cover;
}

/* Content Container */
.wm-mention-content-wrapper {
    display: flex;
    flex-direction: column;
    gap: 12px;
}

/* Author Name */
.wm-author-name {
    font-size: 1.6rem;
    font-weight: var(--font-weight-three-bold);
    color: var(--color-font-one);
    text-decoration: underline;
}

/* Content */
.wm-mention-content {
    font-size: 1.6rem;
    color: var(--color-font-one);
    line-height: 1.5;
}

/* Source and Date Line */
.wm-mention-source-line {
    font-size: 1.6rem;
    color: var(--color-font-two);
}

.wm-mention-source {
    color: var(--ghost-accent-color);
    text-decoration: underline;
}

.wm-mention-metadata {
  font-size: 1.6rem;
}
  
</style>
<script src="/assets/js/webmention.js" async></script>

Remove Ghost comments

Modify your post.hbs template to replace native comments with webmentions:

<div class="post-content">
    {{#if access}}
        {{content}}
        {{^is "page"}}
            {{>posts/share}}
            <div id="webmentions"></div>
        {{/is}}
    {{else}}
        {{#if html}}
            <div class="members-cta-teaser">
                {{{html}}}
            </div>
        {{/if}}
        {{>members/cta}}
    {{/if}}
</div>

Install Webmention Handler

Create webmention.js in your assets/js directory. Also update fetchWebmentions function to handle www and non-www URLs:

class WebmentionHandler {
  constructor(targetSelector = '#webmentions') {
      this.targetSelector = targetSelector;
      this.container = null;
      this.cache = new Map();
      this.initialized = false;
  }

  init() {
      if (this.initialized) return;
      
      // Wait for DOM to be ready
      if (document.readyState === 'loading') {
          document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', () => this.setup());
      } else {
          this.setup();
      }
      
      this.initialized = true;
  }

  setup() {
      this.container = document.querySelector(this.targetSelector);
      if (!this.container) {
          console.log('Webmention container not found');
          return;
      }

      // Show loading state
      this.container.innerHTML = '<div class="wm-loading">Loading mentions...</div>';
      
      const pageUrl = window.location.href.replace(/#.*$/, '');
      console.log('Fetching webmentions for:', pageUrl);
      
      this.fetchWebmentions(pageUrl)
          .then(mentions => this.renderWebmentions(mentions))
          .catch(error => this.handleError(error));
  }

  async fetchWebmentions(targetUrl) {
        // Check cache first
        if (this.cache.has(targetUrl)) {
            return this.cache.get(targetUrl);
        }

        try {
            // Create both www and non-www versions of the URL
            const url = new URL(targetUrl);
            let targets = [];
            
            // If URL has www, add non-www version
            if (url.hostname.startsWith('www.')) {
                targets.push(targetUrl);
                targets.push(targetUrl.replace('www.', ''));
            } else {
                // If URL doesn't have www, add www version
                targets.push(targetUrl);
                targets.push(targetUrl.replace('://', '://www.'));
            }

            // Create the endpoint URL with both targets
            const endpoint = 'https://webmention.io/api/mentions.jf2?' + 
                targets.map(t => 'target[]=' + encodeURIComponent(t)).join('&');
                
            console.log('Fetching from endpoint:', endpoint);

            const response = await fetch(endpoint);
            
            if (!response.ok) {
                throw new Error(`HTTP error! status: ${response.status}`);
            }
            
            const data = await response.json();
            console.log('Received webmentions:', data);

            // Cache both URL versions
            targets.forEach(t => this.cache.set(t, data));
            
            return data;
        } catch (error) {
            console.error('Error fetching webmentions:', error);
            throw error;
        }
    }

  renderWebmentions(data) {
    if (!this.container) return;

    if (!data.children || data.children.length === 0) {
        this.container.innerHTML = '<div class="wm-empty">No mentions yet</div>';
        return;
    }

    // Group by type
    const reactions = data.children.filter(m => 
        ['like-of', 'repost-of', 'bookmark-of'].includes(m['wm-property'])
    );
    const mentions = data.children.filter(m => 
        ['mention-of', 'in-reply-to'].includes(m['wm-property'])
    );

    let html = '<div class="wm-container">';

    // Render header and reactions grid
    html += `
        <h3 class="wm-header">Mentions around the web</h3>
        <div class="wm-avatar-grid">
            ${reactions.map(reaction => this.renderAvatar(reaction)).join('')}
            <span class="wm-reactions-count">${reactions.length} Likes and Retweets</span>
        </div>
    `;

    // Render mentions/comments with show more functionality
    if (mentions.length > 0) {
        html += `
            <div class="wm-mentions-list">
                ${mentions.map(mention => this.renderMention(mention)).join('')}
            </div>
            ${mentions.length > 4 ? 
                `<button class="wm-show-more">Show ${mentions.length - 4} more</button>` : 
                ''
            }
        `;
    }

    html += '</div>';
    this.container.innerHTML = html;

    // Add show more functionality
    const showMoreBtn = this.container.querySelector('.wm-show-more');
    if (showMoreBtn) {
        showMoreBtn.addEventListener('click', () => {
            this.container.querySelector('.wm-mentions-list').classList.add('wm-show-all');
            showMoreBtn.style.display = 'none';
        });
    }
  }


  renderAvatar(reaction) {
      const author = reaction.author || {};
      const defaultAvatar = 'https://webmention.io/avatar/default.svg';
      
      return `
          <a href="${reaction.url}" 
             class="wm-avatar-link" 
             target="_blank" 
             rel="noopener noreferrer"
             title="${author.name || 'Someone'} ${this.getReactionText(reaction['wm-property'])}">
              <img src="${author.photo || defaultAvatar}"
                   alt="${author.name || 'Anonymous'}"
                   loading="lazy"
                   class="wm-avatar-img"
                   onerror="this.src='${defaultAvatar}'">
          </a>
      `;
  }

  renderMention(mention) {
    const author = mention.author || {};
    const date = new Date(mention.published || mention['wm-received'])
        .toLocaleDateString('en-US', {
            year: 'numeric',
            month: 'long',
            day: 'numeric'
        });

    return `
        <div class="wm-mention-item">
            <img src="${author.photo || 'https://webmention.io/avatar/default.svg'}"
                 alt="${author.name || 'Anonymous'}"
                 loading="lazy"
                 class="wm-author-img">
            
            <div class="wm-mention-content-wrapper">
                <div class="wm-mention-header">
                    <a href="${author.url || mention.url}" 
                       class="wm-author-name" 
                       target="_blank" 
                       rel="noopener noreferrer">
                        ${author.name || 'Anonymous'}
                    </a>
                    <span class="wm-mention-metadata">
                        ${this.getMentionType(mention['wm-property'])} on
                        <a href="${mention.url}" 
                           class="wm-mention-source" 
                           target="_blank" 
                           rel="noopener noreferrer">
                            ${this.getSourceName(mention.url)}
                        </a>
                        — ${date}
                    </span>
                </div>
                ${mention.content?.text ? `
                    <div class="wm-mention-content">
                        ${this.formatContent(mention.content.text)}
                    </div>
                ` : ''}
            </div>
        </div>
    `;
  }


  getReactionText(type) {
      const texts = {
          'like-of': 'liked this',
          'repost-of': 'reposted this',
          'bookmark-of': 'bookmarked this'
      };
      return texts[type] || 'reacted to this';
  }

  getMentionType(type) {
      const types = {
          'mention-of': 'mentioned',
          'in-reply-to': 'replied to'
      };
      return types[type] || 'mentioned';
  }

  getSourceName(url) {
      try {
          const hostname = new URL(url).hostname.replace('www.', '');
          // Get first part of domain and capitalize it
          return hostname.split('.')[0].charAt(0).toUpperCase() + hostname.split('.')[0].slice(1);
      } catch (e) {
          return 'Link';
      }
  }

  formatContent(text) {
      // Escape HTML
      const escaped = text.replace(/[&<>"']/g, char => ({
          '&': '&amp;',
          '<': '&lt;',
          '>': '&gt;',
          '"': '&quot;',
          "'": '&#39;'
      }[char]));

      // Truncate if too long
      const maxLength = 280;
      if (escaped.length > maxLength) {
          return escaped.substring(0, maxLength) + '...';
      }

      return escaped;
  }

  handleError(error) {
      if (!this.container) return;
      console.error('Webmention error:', error);
      this.container.innerHTML = '<div class="wm-error">Error loading mentions</div>';
  }
}

// Initialize webmentions
const webmentions = new WebmentionHandler();
webmentions.init();

Configure Brid.gy Integration

Here’s the challenge: When you write a blog post, the conversations about it scatter across the internet like dandelion seeds in the wind. Someone shares it on Mastodon, another person discusses it on Bluesky, while others might reference it in their own blog posts.

This is where Brid.gy bridges the gap. When someone interacts with your syndicated content – whether through likes, reposts, or thoughtful replies – Brid.gy performs a crucial translation:

  1. It captures these interactions from social platforms
  2. Transforms them into standardized webmentions
  3. Sends them back to your blog via webmention.io

The magic happens in this translation layer. A Mastodon boost becomes a webmention your blog understands. A Bluesky reply transforms into a comment that appears below your original post. This creates a unified conversation where your blog becomes the central hub of discussion, not just the starting point.

Brid.gy’s real power lies in its bidirectional syndication:

Your Blog Post → Brid.gy → Mastodon, Reddit, Bluesky etc
Mastodon, Reddit, Bluesky etc → Brid.gy → Webmentions → Your Blog

Mastodon Setup

  1. Go to brid.gy
  2. Navigate to Mastodon section
  3. Input your Mastodon instance URL
  4. Authenticate your account
  5. Enable backfeeding
  6. Save your Micropub token

Bluesky Setup

  1. On brid.gy, locate Bluesky section
  2. Click “Get token”
  3. Enter your Bluesky handle
  4. Enable publishing and response tracking
  5. Store Micropub token securely

Testing Your Implementation

  1. Publish a new blog post
  2. Share it on connected social platforms
  3. Verify webmentions appear on your post
  4. Check console for any errors
  5. Verify URL handling works for both www and non-www variants

And that’s it. By implementing webmentions on your Ghost blog, you’re not just adding a feature - you’re joining a movement toward a more open, interconnected web.

The web was never meant to be a collection of isolated platforms. Your digital homestead awaits.

Update: This was implemented for my previous version of my web page which was on Ghost. Now that I’ve written the new site on Astro JS, I would still have to rewrite this implementation for my new home.

Subscribe to get future posts via email (or grab the RSS feed). 2-3 ideas every month across design and tech

Read more

  1. Home is where the feeling of home residesreflections
  2. Notes on doing most good, doing some good, and living goodphilanthropy
  3. Notes on Londontravel
  4. 18 key ideas from reading Henrik Karlsson this monthwriting
  5. Stop arguing, and start drawing circles togethermathematics
  6. The whole world is just the snake eating its own tailmental-models
  7. Life lessons and hot takes from my 30slifestyle
  8. Building a skill for coherent science illustrationsscience
  9. My agentic engineering workflow (step by step)agentic-coding
  10. Hammock driven developmentagentic-coding
  11. Peculiar ways number three fits into our funny little brainsmental-models
  12. AI sandwich as a defacto principle for anything agentic engineering relatedagentic-coding
  13. Authority in the guise of evidencecritical-rationalism
  14. Map is not the territoryphilosophy
  15. Self hypnosis as a manifestation ritualmeditation
  16. Hegelian dialectic for structured reasoning with AI agentsphilosophy
  17. How I prepare for tough negotiations nowadaysnegotiation
  18. When should we steelthread somethingproduct-development
  19. Breadboarding, shaping, slicing, and steelthreading solutions with AI agentsproduct
  20. Healthy conflict in teams have a tipping pointteam-building
  21. How I deslopify AI writingwriting
  22. How I started building softwares with AI agents being non technicalagentic-coding
  23. Read raw transcriptswriting
  24. Legible and illegible tasks in organisationsproduct
  25. L2 Fat marker sketchesdesign
  26. Writing as moats for humanswriting
  27. Beauty of second degree probesdecision-making
  28. Boundary objects as the new prototypesprototyping
  29. One way door decisionsproduct
  30. Finished softwares should existproduct
  31. How I periodically rank my rough draftsobsidian
  32. Flipping questions on its headinterviewing
  33. Vibe writing maximswriting
  34. How I blog with Obsidian, Cloudflare, AstroJS, Githubwriting
  35. How I build greenfield apps with AI-assisted codingagentic-coding
  36. We have been scammed by the Gaussian distribution clubmathematics
  37. Classify incentive problems into stag hunts, and prisoners dilemmasgame-theory
  38. I was wrong about optimal stoppingmathematics
  39. Thinking like a shipmental-models
  40. Hyperpersonalised N=1 learningeducation
  41. New mediums for humans to complement superintelligenceagentic-coding
  42. Maxims for AI assisted codingagentic-coding
  43. Virtual bookshelvesaesthetics
  44. It's computational and AI everythingagentic-coding
  45. Public gardens, secret routesdigital-garden
  46. Git way of learning to codeagentic-coding
  47. Style Transfer in AI writingagentic-coding
  48. Understanding codebases without using codeagentic-coding
  49. Vibe coding with Cursoragentic-coding
  50. Virtuoso Guide for Personal Memory Systemsmemory
  51. Writing in Future Pastwriting
  52. Publish Originally, Syndicate Elsewhereblogging
  53. Poetic License of Designdesign
  54. Idea in the shower, testing before breakfastsoftware
  55. Technology and regulation have a dance of ice and firetechnology
  56. How I ship "stuff"software
  57. Writing is thinkingwriting
  58. Song of Shapes, Words and Pathscreativity
  59. How do we absorb ideas better?knowledge
  60. Read writers who operatewriting
  61. Brew your ideas lazilyideas
  62. Trees, Branches, Twigs and Leaves — Mental Models for Writingwriting
  63. Compound Interest of Private Noteswriting
  64. Conceptual Compression for LLMsagentic-coding
  65. Meta-analysis for contradictory research findingsdigital-health
  66. Proof of workproduct
  67. Gauging previous work of new joinees to the teamleadership
  68. Task management for product managersproduct
  69. Beauty of Zettelswriting
  70. Stitching React and Rails togetheragentic-coding
  71. Exploring "smart connections" for note takingwriting
  72. Deploying Home Cooked Apps with Railssoftware
  73. Repetitive Copypromptingwriting
  74. Questions to ask every decadejournalling
  75. Balancing work, time and focusproductivity
  76. Hyperlinks are like cashew nutswriting
  77. Brand treatments, Design Systems, Vibesdesign
  78. How to spot human writing on the internetwriting
  79. Can a thought be an algorithm?product
  80. Opportunity Harvestingcareers
  81. Everything is a prioritisation problemproduct
  82. How I do product roastsproduct
  83. The Modern Startup Stacksoftware
  84. In-person vision transmissionproduct
  85. How might we help children invent for social good?social-design
  86. The meeting before the meetingmeetings
  87. Design that's so bad it's actually gooddesign
  88. Lessons learnt interview prepping for product rolesinterviewing
  89. Obsessing over personal websitessoftware
  90. English is the hot new programming languagesoftware
  91. Better way to think about conflictsrisk-management
  92. The role of taste in building productsdesign
  93. Dear enterprises, we're tired of your subscriptionssoftware
  94. Products need not be user centereddesign
  95. World's most ancient public health problemsoftware
  96. Pluginisation of Modern Softwaredesign
  97. Let's make every work 'strategic'consulting
  98. Making Nielsen's heuristics more digestibledesign
  99. Startups are a fertile ground for risk takingentrepreneurship
  100. Insights are not just a salad of factsdesign
  101. Minimum Lovable Productproduct
  102. Methods are lifejackets not straight jacketsmethodology
  103. How to arrive at on-brand colours?design
  104. Minto principle for writing memoswriting
  105. Importance of Whytask-management
  106. Quality Ideas Trump Executionsoftware
  107. Why I prefer indie softwareslifestyle
  108. Use code only if no code failscode
  109. Self Marketing
  110. Personal Observation Techniquesdesign
  111. Design is a confusing worddesign
  112. A Primer to Service Design Blueprintsdesign
  113. Rapid Journey Prototypingdesign
  114. Visualise detailed file structures on CLIcli
  115. Do's and Don'ts of User Researchdesign
  116. Design Manifestodesign
  117. Complex project management for productproducts
  118. How might we enable patients and caregivers to overcome preventable health conditions?digital-health
  119. Pedagogy of the Uncharted — What for, and Where to?education
  120. Future of Equity with Ludovick Petersinterviewing
  121. Future of Ageing with Mehdi Yacoubiinterviewing
  122. Future of Tacit knowledge with Celeste Volpiinterviewing
  123. Future of Mental Health with Kavya Raointerviewing
  124. Future of unschooling with Che Vanniinterviewing
  125. Future of Rural Innovation with Thabiso Blak Mashabainterviewing
  126. Future of work with Laetitia Vitaudinterviewing
  127. How might we prevent acquired infections in hospitals?digital-health
  128. The why to endure any howentrepreneurship
  129. Design education amidst social tribulationsdesign
  130. How might we assist deafblind runners to navigate?social-design